| Platinum | Whiskey and The Wolf |
| Gold | Mason Jar |
| Silver | Maumee Bay Brew Pub |
| Bronze | Fricker's |
| Top Pick | Attic On Adams/Mano's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Holy Toledo Tavern |
| Top Pick | John's Korner Bar |
| Top Pick | Mayfly Tavern |
| Top Pick | The Ottawa Tavern |
| Top Pick | The Village Idiot |