| Platinum | Crumbl Cookies - Sylvania |
| Gold | Cookie Lady |
| Silver | Barry Bagels |
| Bronze | Michael's Cafe & Bakery |
| Top Pick | Cookiecuterie |
| Top Pick | Crowned Cakes by Jess |
| Top Pick | Fresh Thyme Farmers Market- Toledo |
| Top Pick | Jeras Heavenly Sweet Bakery |
| Top Pick | Jessicakes |
| Top Pick | Salad Galley |