| Platinum | Schmucker's Restaurant |
| Gold | Manhattan's Restaurant |
| Silver | Fricker's |
| Bronze | Mamas Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Brickhouse Restaurant and Bar |
| Top Pick | Brim House |
| Top Pick | Classic Cafe |
| Top Pick | Dave & Buster's |
| Top Pick | Fowl and Fodder |
| Top Pick | Rudy's Hot Dog |