| Platinum | Gino's Italian Delites |
| Gold | Inky's Italian Foods |
| Silver | Dandino's Pizza & More |
| Bronze | Home Slice Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bambinos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Guys Pizza |
| Top Pick | Hindsight Pizza |
| Top Pick | The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar |
| Top Pick | The Village Idiot |
| Top Pick | Vito's |