| Platinum | Maumee Valley Save-a-Pet |
| Gold | Toledo Juneteeth Celebration |
| Silver | East Toledo Family Center |
| Bronze | Good Grief of Northwest Ohio |
| Top Pick | Mom's House Inc of Toledo |
| Top Pick | Operation Saves |
| Top Pick | Paws & Whiskers Cat Shelter |
| Top Pick | Sisters 4 Unity |
| Top Pick | Sofia Quintero Arts & Cultural Center (Sqacc) |
| Top Pick | Zepf Center |