| Platinum | Tokyo Steakhouse & Sushi |
| Gold | Schmucker's Restaurant |
| Silver | The Icy Paw LLC |
| Bronze | Sylvania Nutrition |
| Top Pick | City Barbeque |
| Top Pick | Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant (Toledo, OH) |
| Top Pick | El Tipico Restaurant |
| Top Pick | River Diner |
| Top Pick | Souk Mediterranean Kitchen and Bar |
| Top Pick | Ye Olde Durty Bird |